Baire property is open subspace-closed: Difference between revisions

From Topospaces
No edit summary
Line 23: Line 23:
==Proof==
==Proof==


'''Given''': A Baire space <math>X</math>, an open subset <math>A</math>
'''Given''': A Baire space <math>X</math>, an open subset <math>A</math>. A countable family of open dense subsets, <math>U_n, n \in \mathbb{N}</math> of <math>A</math>


'''To prove''': An intersection of a countable family of open dense subsets, <math>U_n, n \in \mathbb{N}</math> of <math>A</math> is dense in <math>A</math>
'''To prove''': The intersection <math>\bigcap_{n \in \mathbb{N}} U_n</math> is dense in <math>A</math>


'''Proof''': First, consider the set <math>B = X \setminus \overline{A}</math>, where <math>\overline{A}</math> is the closure of <math>A</math> in <math>X</math>. Clearly <math>B</math> is open in <math>X</math>.
'''Proof''':  


Since <math>A</math> is open in <math>X</math>, and each <math>U_n</math> is open in <math>A</math>, each <math>U_n</math> is open in <math>X</math>. Hence, each <math>U_n \cup B</math> is open in <math>X</math>.
{| class="sortable" border="1"
! Step no. !! Assertion/construction !! Facts used !! Given data used !! Previous steps used !! Explanation
|-
| 1 || Consider the set <math>B = X \setminus \overline{A}</math>, where <math>\overline{A}</math> is the closure of <math>A</math> in <math>X</math>. <math>B</math> is an '''open''' subset of <math>X</math>. || || || || the complement of a closed subset is open by definition.
|-
| 2 || Each <math>U_n</math> is open in <math>X</math>. || || <math>A</math> is open in <math>X</math><br>Each <math>U_n</math> is open in <math>A</math>. || ||
|-
| 3 || Each <math>U_n \cup B</math> is open in <math>X</math> with <math>B</math> defined in Step (1). || || || Steps (1), (2) || Step-combination, and the observation that a union of open subsets is open
|-
| 4 || Each <math>U_n \cup B</math> is dense in <math>X</math>. In other words, for any open subset <math>V</math> of <math>X</math>, the intersection <math>(U_n \cup B) \cap V</math> is nonempty. || || || || <toggledisplay>Consider any open subset <math>V</math> of <math>X</math>. If the open subset intersects <math>B</math>, we are done. Otherwise the open subset is in <math>\overline{A}</math>. Hence, by definition, it intersects <math>A</math> in a nonempty open subset, say <math>W</math>. Then <math>W</math> is an open subset of <math>A</math>. Since <math>U_n</math> is dense in <math>A</math>, it intersects <math>W</math> nontrivially, so it intersects <math>V</math> nontrivially, completing the proof of density.</toggledisplay>
|-
| 5 || Consider the collection of subsets <math>U_n \cup B</math>. This is a countable collection of open dense subsets of <math>X</math> || || || Steps (3), (4) || Step-combination direct
|-
| 6 || The intersection <math>\bigcap_{n \in \mathbb{N}} (U_n \cup B)</math> is dense in <math>X</math>> || || <math>X</math> is a Baire space. || Step (5) || Step-given direct
|}


Next, we want to argue that each <math>U_n \cup B</math> is dense in <math>X</math>. For this, consider any open subset <math>V</math> of <math>X</math>. If the open subset intersects <math>B</math>, we are done. Otherwise the open subset is in <math>\overline{A}</math>. Hence, by definition, it intersects <math>A</math> in a nonempty open subset, say <math>W</math>. Then <math>W</math> is an open subset of <math>A</math>. Since <math>U_n</math> is dense in <math>A</math>, it intersects <math>W</math> nontrivially, completing the proof of density.
The rest of the proof needs to be converted to tabular form too!


Thus, consider the collection of subsets <math>U_n \cup B</math>. This is a countable collection of open dense subsets of <math>X</math>, so their intersection is dense in <math>X</math>. This intersection is of the form <math>B \cup T</math>, where <math>T</math> is an open subset of <math>A</math>. We now need to argue that <math>T</math> is a dense subset of <math>A</math>.
so their intersection is dense in <math>X</math>. This intersection is of the form <math>B \cup T</math>, where <math>T</math> is an open subset of <math>A</math>. We now need to argue that <math>T</math> is a dense subset of <math>A</math>.


Let <math>S</math> be a nonempty open subset of <math>A</math>; we need to show that <math>S \cap T</math> is nonempty. Since <math>S</math> is open in <math>A</math>, <math>S</math> is also open in <math>X</math>, so <math>S \cap (T \cup B)</math> is nonempty, because <math>T \cup B</math> is dense in <math>X</math>. But since <math>S \subset A</math>, <math>S \cap B</math> is empty, so <math>S \cap T</math> must be nonempty, completing the proof.
Let <math>S</math> be a nonempty open subset of <math>A</math>; we need to show that <math>S \cap T</math> is nonempty. Since <math>S</math> is open in <math>A</math>, <math>S</math> is also open in <math>X</math>, so <math>S \cap (T \cup B)</math> is nonempty, because <math>T \cup B</math> is dense in <math>X</math>. But since <math>S \subset A</math>, <math>S \cap B</math> is empty, so <math>S \cap T</math> must be nonempty, completing the proof.

Revision as of 00:19, 25 January 2012

This article gives the statement, and possibly proof, of a topological space property (i.e., Baire space) satisfying a topological space metaproperty (i.e., open subspace-closed property of topological spaces)
View all topological space metaproperty satisfactions | View all topological space metaproperty dissatisfactions
Get more facts about Baire space |Get facts that use property satisfaction of Baire space | Get facts that use property satisfaction of Baire space|Get more facts about open subspace-closed property of topological spaces

Statement

Verbal statement

Every open subset of a Baire space is itself a Baire space, under the subspace topology.

Definitions used

Baire space

Further information: Baire space

A topological space is termed a Baire space if an intersection of countably many open dense subsets is dense.

Subspace topology

Further information: Subspace topology

Proof

Given: A Baire space X, an open subset A. A countable family of open dense subsets, Un,nN of A

To prove: The intersection nNUn is dense in A

Proof:

Step no. Assertion/construction Facts used Given data used Previous steps used Explanation
1 Consider the set B=XA¯, where A¯ is the closure of A in X. B is an open subset of X. the complement of a closed subset is open by definition.
2 Each Un is open in X. A is open in X
Each Un is open in A.
3 Each UnB is open in X with B defined in Step (1). Steps (1), (2) Step-combination, and the observation that a union of open subsets is open
4 Each UnB is dense in X. In other words, for any open subset V of X, the intersection (UnB)V is nonempty. [SHOW MORE]
5 Consider the collection of subsets UnB. This is a countable collection of open dense subsets of X Steps (3), (4) Step-combination direct
6 The intersection nN(UnB) is dense in X> X is a Baire space. Step (5) Step-given direct

The rest of the proof needs to be converted to tabular form too!

so their intersection is dense in X. This intersection is of the form BT, where T is an open subset of A. We now need to argue that T is a dense subset of A.

Let S be a nonempty open subset of A; we need to show that ST is nonempty. Since S is open in A, S is also open in X, so S(TB) is nonempty, because TB is dense in X. But since SA, SB is empty, so ST must be nonempty, completing the proof.

References

Textbook references

  • Topology (2nd edition) by James R. Munkres, More info, Page 297, Lemma 48.4, Chapter 4, Section 48