Weak homotopy equivalence of topological spaces
This article defines a property of continuous maps between topological spaces
Definition
Definition for path-connected spaces in terms of homotopy groups
Let
and
be path-connected spaces. A weak homotopy equivalence from
to
is a continuous map
such that the functorially induced maps
are group isomorphisms for all
.
Note that since the maps are homomorphisms anyway, it is enough to require them to be bijective.
Basepoint choice disclaimer for homotopy group isomorphism: To concretely define the map
, we need to choose basepoints for
and
. Change of basepoint, however, only results in pre-composition and post-composition by isomorphisms and does not affect whether or not the map is an isomorphism.
Equivalent definition for path-connected spaces in terms of homology groups
Let
and
be path-connected spaces. Then a continuous map
is a weak homotopy equivalence iff both of these conditions hold:
- The induced map
is an isomorphism of groups. - For every bundle of abelian groups
over
, the induced map of twisted homology groups
is an isomorphism of groups for all
.
As above, all of these maps are homomorphisms anyway, so it is enough to require them to be bijective. The above basepoint disclaimer for
also applies here.
If both
and
are simply connected then the criterion is simpler: a continuous map
is a weak homotopy equivalence iff the induced map on homology with
coefficients
is an isomorphism of groups for all
.
Definition for spaces that are not path-connected
Let
and
be topological spaces. A weak homotopy equivalence from
to
is a continuous map
such that:
- The functorially induced map
is a bijection between the set of path components
and the set of path components
. - For every path component of
, the restriction of
to a continuous map from that to its image path component of
is a weak homotopy equivalence of path-connected spaces.
Facts
- The existence of a weak homotopy equivalence from
to
does not imply the existence of a weak homotopy equivalence from
to
. Thus, to get an equivalence relation on topological spaces, we need to take a symmetric transitive closure. We say that spaces are weak homotopy-equivalent topological spaces if they are in the same equivalence class under the equivalence relation thus obtained. - The mere fact that
as abstract groups is not enough to guarantee that
and
are weak homotopy-equivalent, even when
and
are manifolds or CW-spaces (see isomorphic homotopy groups not implies weak homotopy-equivalent). Rather, it is specifically important that the map must induce those isomorphisms. - The exception to the above is in the case that both
and
are the trivial group/one-point set for all
. In this case, any map must induce isomorphisms since that's the only possible map between trivial groups/one-point sets. In this case, the spaces
and
are both weakly contractible spaces. - Similarly, the mere fact that
as abstract groups and
as abstract groups does not imply that
and
are weak homotopy-equivalent. See isomorphic homology groups and isomorphic fundamental groups not implies weak homotopy-equivalent. Rather, it is specifically important that the map must induce those isomorphisms. - The exception to the above is, once again, where the fundamental group and all the homology groups
, are trivial.