Normal Hausdorff space: Difference between revisions

From Topospaces
No edit summary
 
(25 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{pivotal topospace property}}
''There are two alternative definitions of the term. Please see:'' [[Convention:Hausdorffness assumption]]
==Definition==


{{T family|T4}}
===Equivalent definitions in tabular format===


{{basicdef}}
{| class="sortable" border="1"
! No. !! Shorthand !! A topological space is said to be normal Hausdorff if ... !! A topological space <math>X</math> is said to be normal Hausdorff if ...
|-
| 1 || separation of disjoint closed subsets by open subsets || all points in it are closed sets, ''and'' given any two disjoint [[closed subset]]s in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets containing them. || for all <math>x \in X</math>, the set <math>\{ x \}</math> is closed in <math>X</math>, ''and'' given any two closed subsets <math>A,B \subseteq X</math> such that <math>A \cap B = \varnothing</math>, there exist disjoint open subsets <math>U,V</math> of <math>X</math> such that <math>A \subseteq U, B \subseteq V</math>, and <math>U \cap V = \varnothing</math>.
|-
| 2 || separation of disjoint closed subsets by continuous functions || all points in it are closed sets, ''and'' given any two disjoint closed subsets, there is a continuous function taking the value <math>0</math> at one closed set and 1 at the other. || For all <math>x \in X</math>, the set <math>\{ x \}</math> is closed in <math>X</math>, and for any two closed subsets <math>A,B \subseteq X</math>, such that <math>A \cap B = \varnothing</math>, there exists a [[continuous map]] <math>f:X \to [0,1]</math> (to the [[closed unit interval]]) such that <math>f(x) = 0 \ \forall x \in A</math> and <math>f(x) = 1 \ \forall \ x \in B</math>.
|-
| 3 || point-finite open cover has shrinking || all points are closed, ''and'' every [[defining ingredient::point-finite collection|point-finite]] [[open cover]] possesses a [[shrinking]]. || for all <math>x \in X</math>, the set <math>\{ x \}</math> is closed in <math>X</math>, and for any point-finite open cover <math>U_i, i \in I</math> of <math>X</math>, there exists a shrinking <math>V_i, i \in I</math>: the <math>V_i</math> form an open cover and <math>\overline{V_i} \subseteq U_i</math>.
|-
| 4 || separation of finitely many disjoint closed subsets by open subsets || all points in it are closed sets, ''and'' given a finite collection of pairwise disjoint [[closed subset]]s in the topological space, there are pairwise disjoint open sets containing them. || for all <math>x \in X</math>, the set <math>\{ x \}</math> is closed in <math>X</math>, ''and'' given any finite collection of pairwise disjoint closed subsets <math>A_1,A_2,\dots,A_n \subseteq X</math>, there exist pairwise disjoint open subsets <math>U_1,U_2, \dots, U_n</math> of <math>X</math> such that <math>A_i \subseteq U_i</math> for all <math>i</math>.
|}


{{surveyarticles|[[:Category:Survey articles related to normality]]}}
Note that in each of the definitions, the [[T1 space]] assumption (that points are closed) can be replaced by the (a priori stronger) [[Hausdorff space]] assumption, without changing the meaning of the overall definition.


==Definition==
Some people use the term ''normal space'' for what is called here a normal Hausdorff space; however, we define the term [[normal space]] as ''not'' having the [[T1 space]] assumption.


===Symbol-free definition===
===Equivalence of definitions===


A [[topological space]] is said to be '''normal''' if it satisfies the following equivalent conditions:
The direction (2) implies (1) is easy: if there is a continuous function <math>f:X \to [0,1]</math> such that <math>A \subseteq f^{-1}(\{ 0 \})</math> and <math>B \subseteq f^{-1}(\{ 1 \})</math>, then we can take the open sets <math>f^{-1}((0,1/2))</math> and <math>f^{-1}((1/2,1))</math>.


* All points in it are closed sets, and given any two disjoint [[closed subset]]s in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets containing them.
The direction (1) implies (2) follows from [[Urysohn's lemma]].
* All points in it are closed sets, and given any two disjoint closed subsets, there is a continuous function taking the value 0 at one closed set and 1 at the other
* All points are closed, and every [[point-finite collection|point-finite]] open cover possesses a [[shrinking]]


===Definition with symbols===
{{basicdef}}
{{pivotal topospace property}}


{{fillin}}
{{T family|T4}}


==Relation with other properties==
==Relation with other properties==
Line 25: Line 35:
{{pivotalproperty}}
{{pivotalproperty}}


* [[:Category:Variations of normality]]
* {{#ask: [[variation of::normal space]]|limit = 0|searchlabel = View all variations of normality}}


===Stronger properties===
===Stronger properties===


* [[Compact Hausdorff space]]
{| class="sortable" border="1"
* [[Hereditarily normal space]]
! Property !! Meaning !! Proof of implication !! Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) !! Intermediate notions
* [[Paracompact Hausdorff space]]
|-
* [[Regular Lindelof space]]
| [[Weaker than::Compact Hausdorff space]] || a [[compact space]] that is also [[Hausdorff space|Hausdorff]] || [[compact Hausdorff implies normal]] || [[normal not implies compact]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|compact Hausdorff space}}
* [[Perfectly normal space]]
|-
* [[Metrizable space]]
| [[Weaker than::Hereditarily normal space]] || every subspace is a [[normal space]] under the [[subspace topology]] || || [[normality is not hereditary]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|hereditarily normal space}}
* [[CW-space]]
|-
* [[Linearly orderable space]]
| [[Weaker than::Paracompact Hausdorff space]] || a [[paracompact space]] that is also [[Hausdorff space|Hausdorff]] || [[paracompact Hausdorff implies normal]] || [[normal not implies paracompact]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|paracompact Hausdorff space}}
* [[Collectionwise normal space]]
|-
| [[Weaker than::Regular Lindelof space]] || both a [[regular space]] and a [[Lindelof space]] || [[regular Lindelof implies normal]] || [[normal not implies Lindelof]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|regular Lindelof space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::Perfectly normal space]] || every [[closed subset]] is a [[G-delta subset]] || [[perfectly normal implies normal]] || [[normal not implies perfectly normal]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|perfectly normal space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::Metrizable space]] || can be given the structure of a [[metric space]] with the same topology || [[metrizable implies normal]] || [[normal not implies metrizable]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|metrizable space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::CW-space]] || the underlying topological space of a [[CW-complex]] || [[CW implies normal]] || [[normal not implies CW]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|CW-space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::Linearly orderable space]] || obtained using the order topology for some linear ordering || [[linearly orderable implies normal]] || [[normal not implies linearly orderable]] || {{intermediate notions short|normal space|linearly orderable space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::Collectionwise normal space]] || || || ||
|-
| [[Weaker than::Monotonically normal space]] || || || ||
|}


===Weaker properties===
===Weaker properties===


* [[Completely regular space]]: {{proofofstrictimplicationat|[[normal implies completely regular]]|[[completely regular not implies normal]]}}
{| class="sortable" border="1"
* [[Regular space]]: {{proofofstrictimplicationat|[[normal implies regular]]|[[regular not implies normal]]}}
! Property !! Meaning !! Proof of implication !! Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) !! Intermediate notions
* [[Hausdorff space]]
|-
* [[T1 space]]
| [[Stronger than::Completely regular space]] (also called <math>T_{3.5}</math>) || continuous function taking 0 at point, 1 at disjoint closed set || [[normal implies completely regular]] || [[completely regular not implies normal]] || {{intermediate notions short|completely regular space|normal space}}
* [[Kolmogorov space]]
|-
| [[Stronger than::Regular space]] (also called <math>T_3</math>) || open subsets separating point and disjoint closed subset || [[normal implies regular]] || [[regular not implies normal]] || {{intermediate notions short|regular space|normal space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::Hausdorff space]] || open subsets separating distinct points || (via regular) || (via regular) || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|normal space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::T1 space]] || every point is closed || by definition || (via Hausdorff, regular) || {{intermediate notions short|T1 space|normal space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::Kolmogorov space]] (also called <math>T_0</math>) || for any two points, open subset containing one and not the other || by definition || || {{intermediate notions short|Kolmogorov space|normal space}}
|}


==Metaproperties==
==Metaproperties==


{| class="sortable" border="1"
!Metaproperty name !! Satisfied? !! Proof
|-
| [[dissatisfies metaproperty::product-closed property of topological spaces]] || No || [[normality is not product-closed]]
|-
| [[dissatisfies metaproperty::subspace-hereditary property of topological spaces]] || No || [[normality is not hereditary]]
|-
| [[satisfies metaproperty::weakly hereditary property of topological spaces]] || Yes || [[normality is weakly hereditary]]
|-
| [[dissatisfies metaproperty::refining-preserved property of topological spaces]] || No || [[normality is not refining-preserved]]
|}
Below is more information:<toggledisplay>
{{not DP-closed}}
{{not DP-closed}}


A direct product of normal spaces need not be normal. {{proofat|[[Normality is not product-closed]]}}
A product of two normal spaces, endowed with the [[product topology]], need not be normal. {{proofat|[[Normality is not product-closed]]}}
 
{{not subspace-closed}}
 
It is possible to have a normal space <math>X</math> and a subspace <math>Y</math> of <math>X</math> such that <math>Y</math> is not a normal space. {{proofat|[[Normality is not hereditary]]}}
 
{{further|[[Complete regularity is hereditary]], [[normal implies completely regular]], [[metrizable implies hereditarily normal]], [[CW implies hereditarily normal]]}}


{{closed subspace-closed}}
{{closed subspace-closed}}


Any subspace of a normal space need not be normal. However, any [[closed subset]] of a normal space is normal, under the subspace topology. {{further|[[Normality is weakly hereditary]]}}
Any subspace of a normal space need not be normal. However, any [[closed subset]] of a normal space is normal, under the subspace topology. {{further|[[Normality is weakly hereditary]]}}
{{not refining-preserved}}
Moving to a finer topology, i.e., adding more open subsets, may destroy the property of normality. {{proofat|[[Normality is not refining-preserved]]}}
{{further|[[Hausdorffness is refining-preserved]], [[T1 is refining-preserved]], [[regularity is not refining-preserved]], [[metrizability is not refining-preserved]]}}
</toggledisplay>


==Facts==
==Facts==
Line 72: Line 130:


{{applyingoperatorgives|locally operator|locally normal space}}
{{applyingoperatorgives|locally operator|locally normal space}}
==References==
===Textbook references===
* {{booklink-defined|Munkres}}, Page 195,Chapter 4, Section 31 (formal definition, along with definition of [[regular space]])
* {{booklink-defined|SingerThorpe}}, Page 28 (formal definition)


==External links==
==External links==

Latest revision as of 22:01, 27 January 2012

There are two alternative definitions of the term. Please see: Convention:Hausdorffness assumption

Definition

Equivalent definitions in tabular format

No. Shorthand A topological space is said to be normal Hausdorff if ... A topological space is said to be normal Hausdorff if ...
1 separation of disjoint closed subsets by open subsets all points in it are closed sets, and given any two disjoint closed subsets in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets containing them. for all , the set is closed in , and given any two closed subsets such that , there exist disjoint open subsets of such that , and .
2 separation of disjoint closed subsets by continuous functions all points in it are closed sets, and given any two disjoint closed subsets, there is a continuous function taking the value at one closed set and 1 at the other. For all , the set is closed in , and for any two closed subsets , such that , there exists a continuous map (to the closed unit interval) such that and .
3 point-finite open cover has shrinking all points are closed, and every point-finite open cover possesses a shrinking. for all , the set is closed in , and for any point-finite open cover of , there exists a shrinking : the form an open cover and .
4 separation of finitely many disjoint closed subsets by open subsets all points in it are closed sets, and given a finite collection of pairwise disjoint closed subsets in the topological space, there are pairwise disjoint open sets containing them. for all , the set is closed in , and given any finite collection of pairwise disjoint closed subsets , there exist pairwise disjoint open subsets of such that for all .

Note that in each of the definitions, the T1 space assumption (that points are closed) can be replaced by the (a priori stronger) Hausdorff space assumption, without changing the meaning of the overall definition.

Some people use the term normal space for what is called here a normal Hausdorff space; however, we define the term normal space as not having the T1 space assumption.

Equivalence of definitions

The direction (2) implies (1) is easy: if there is a continuous function such that and , then we can take the open sets and .

The direction (1) implies (2) follows from Urysohn's lemma.


This article is about a basic definition in topology.
VIEW: Definitions built on this | Facts about this | Survey articles about this
View a complete list of basic definitions in topology

This article defines a property of topological space that is pivotal (viz important) among currently studied properties of topological spaces

In the T family (properties of topological spaces related to separation axioms), this is called: T4

Relation with other properties

This property is a pivotal (important) member of its property space. Its variations, opposites, and other properties related to it and defined using it are often studied

Stronger properties

Property Meaning Proof of implication Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) Intermediate notions
Compact Hausdorff space a compact space that is also Hausdorff compact Hausdorff implies normal normal not implies compact Binormal space, Paracompact Hausdorff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Hereditarily normal space every subspace is a normal space under the subspace topology normality is not hereditary |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Paracompact Hausdorff space a paracompact space that is also Hausdorff paracompact Hausdorff implies normal normal not implies paracompact Binormal space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Regular Lindelof space both a regular space and a Lindelof space regular Lindelof implies normal normal not implies Lindelof |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Perfectly normal space every closed subset is a G-delta subset perfectly normal implies normal normal not implies perfectly normal Hereditarily normal space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Metrizable space can be given the structure of a metric space with the same topology metrizable implies normal normal not implies metrizable Collectionwise normal space, Elastic space, Hereditarily collectionwise normal space, Hereditarily normal space, Monotonically normal space, Paracompact Hausdorff space, Perfectly normal space, Protometrizable space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
CW-space the underlying topological space of a CW-complex CW implies normal normal not implies CW Hereditarily normal space, Paracompact Hausdorff space, Perfectly normal space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Linearly orderable space obtained using the order topology for some linear ordering linearly orderable implies normal normal not implies linearly orderable Collectionwise normal space, Hereditarily collectionwise normal space, Hereditarily normal space, Monotonically normal space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Collectionwise normal space
Monotonically normal space

Weaker properties

Property Meaning Proof of implication Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) Intermediate notions
Completely regular space (also called ) continuous function taking 0 at point, 1 at disjoint closed set normal implies completely regular completely regular not implies normal |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Regular space (also called ) open subsets separating point and disjoint closed subset normal implies regular regular not implies normal Completely regular space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Hausdorff space open subsets separating distinct points (via regular) (via regular) Completely regular space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
T1 space every point is closed by definition (via Hausdorff, regular) Completely regular space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Kolmogorov space (also called ) for any two points, open subset containing one and not the other by definition |FULL LIST, MORE INFO

Metaproperties

Metaproperty name Satisfied? Proof
product-closed property of topological spaces No normality is not product-closed
subspace-hereditary property of topological spaces No normality is not hereditary
weakly hereditary property of topological spaces Yes normality is weakly hereditary
refining-preserved property of topological spaces No normality is not refining-preserved

Below is more information:[SHOW MORE]

Facts

Effect of property operators

The subspace operator

Applying the subspace operator to this property gives: completely regular space

A topological space can be realized as a subspace of a normal space iff it is completely regular. Necessity follows from the fact that normal spaces are completely regular, and any subspace of a completely regular space is completely regular. Sufficiency follows from the Stone-Cech compactification.

The hereditarily operator

Applying the hereditarily operator to this property gives: hereditarily normal space

A topological space in which every subspace is normal is termed hereditarily normal (some people call it completely normal). Note that metrizable spaces are hereditarily normal.

The locally operator

Applying the locally operator to this property gives: locally normal space

References

Textbook references

  • Topology (2nd edition) by James R. MunkresMore info, Page 195,Chapter 4, Section 31 (formal definition, along with definition of regular space)
  • Lecture Notes on Elementary Topology and Geometry (Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics) by I. M. Singer and J. A. ThorpeMore info, Page 28 (formal definition)

External links

Definition links