Hausdorff space: Difference between revisions

From Topospaces
 
(28 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{pivotal topospace property}}
''Please also read the Topospaces Convention page:'' [[Convention:Hausdorffness assumption]]


{{T family|T2}}
==Definition==


{{basicdef}}
===Equivalent definitions in tabular format===


{{surveyarticles|[[:Category:Survey articles related to Hausdorffness]]}}
A [[topological space]] is said to be '''Hausdorff''' if it satisfies the following equivalent conditions:


''Please also read the Topospaces Convention page:'' [[Convention:Hausdorffness assumption]]
{| class="sortable" border="1"
! No. !! Shorthand !! A topological space is termed Hausdorff if ... !! A topological space <math>X</math> is termed Hausdorff if ...
|-
| 1 || Separation axiom || given any two distinct points in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets containing the two points respectively. || given any two points <math>x \ne y \in X</math>, there exist [[open subset]]s <math>U \ni x</math> and <math>V \ni y</math> such that <math>U \cap V</math> is empty
|-
| 2 || Diagonal in square || the diagonal is closed in the product of the space with itself || in the product space <math>X \times X</math>, endowed with the [[defining ingredient::product topology]], the diagonal, viz., the subset given by <math>\{ (x,x) \mid x \in X \}</math> is a [[defining ingredient::closed subset]]
|-
| 3 || Ultrafilter convergence || every ultrafilter of subsets converges to at most one point || if <math>S_\alpha</math> is an ultrafilter of subsets of <math>X</math>, then there is at most one <math>x \in X</math> for which <math>S_\alpha \to x</math>.
|-
| 4 || Separation axiom for finite subsets || given any finite collection of distinct points the topological space, there are open subsets containing each of the points in that finite subset that have pairwise trivial intersection. || for any finite collection <math>x_1, x_2, \dots, x_n</math> of distinct points in <math>X</math>, there exists a finite collection <math>U_1, U_2, \dots, U_n</math> of open subsets of <math>X</math> such that <math>U_i \ni x_i</math> for all <math>i</math> and<math>U_i \cap U_j</math> is empty for <math>i \ne j</math>.
|-
| 5 || Separation axiom using basis open subsets || (choose a basis of open subsets for the topological space) given any two distinct points in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets ''from the basis'' containing the two points respectively. || (choose a basis of open subsets for the topological space) given any two points <math>x \ne y \in X</math>, there exist [[open subset]]s <math>U \ni x</math> and <math>V \ni y</math> such that both <math>U</math> and <math>V</math> are in the basis and <math>U \cap V</math> is empty
|-
| 6 || Separation axiom for finite subsets using basis open subsets || (choose a basis of open subsets for the topological space) given any finite collection of distinct points the topological space, there are open subsets (all from the basis) containing each of the points in that finite subset that have pairwise trivial intersection. || for any finite collection <math>x_1, x_2, \dots, x_n</math> of distinct points in <math>X</math>, there exists a finite collection <math>U_1, U_2, \dots, U_n</math> of open subsets of <math>X</math> (all from the basis) such that <math>U_i \ni x_i</math> for all <math>i</math> and<math>U_i \cap U_j</math> is empty for <math>i \ne j</math>.
|-
| 7 || Separation axiom for two compact subsets || any two disjoint compact subsets can be separated by disjoint open subsets || given any compact subsets <math>A_1,A_2</math> of <math>X</math> (i.e., <math>A_1,A_2</math> are both [[compact space]]s in the [[subspace topology]]), there exist disjoint open subsets <math>U_1,U_2</math> such that <math>U_1 \supseteq A_1</math> and <math>U_2\supseteq A_2</math>.
|-
| 8 || Separation axiom for finitely many compact subsets || any finite collection of pairwise disjoint compact subsets can be separated by a finite collection of pairwise disjoint open subsets || given a finite collection <math>A_1,A_2,\dots,A_n</math> of pairwise disjoint compact subsets of <math>X</math>, there exist pairwise disjoint open subsets <math>U_1,U_2,\dots,U_n</math> of <math>X</math> such that <math>A_i \subseteq U_i</math> for each <math>i</math>.
|-
| 9 || Separation axiom between point and compact subset || given any point and any compact subset not contianing it, the point and the compact subset can be separated by disjoint open subsets. || for any <math>x \in X</math> and any <math>A \subseteq X</math> such that <math>A</math> is compact and <math>x \notin A</math>, there exist disjoint open subsets <math>U,V</math> of <math>X</math> such that <math>U \ni x, V \supseteq A</math>.
|-
| 10 ||preregular and Kolmogorov || it is both a [[preregular space]] and a [[Kolmogorov space]] (i.e., a <math>T_0</math> space) ||
|}


==Definition==
===Equivalence of definitions===


===Symbol-free definition===
{{further|[[equivalence of definitions of Hausdorff space]]}}


A [[topological space]] is said to be '''Hausdorff''' if it satisfies the following equivalent conditions:
==Examples==


# Given any two points in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets containing the two points respectively.
===Extreme examples===
# The diagonal is closed in the product of the space with itself
# Every ultrafilter of subsets converges to at most one point


===Definition with symbols===
* The [[empty space]] is a Hausdorff space. For this space, the Hausdorffness condition is vacuously satisfied.
* The [[one-point space]] is a Hausdorff space. For this space, the Hausdorffness condition is vacuously satisfied.
* Any [[discrete space]] (i.e., a topological space with the discrete topology) is a Hausdorff space.


A [[topological space]] <math>X</math> is said to be '''Hausdorff''' if it satisfies the following equivalent conditions:
===Typical examples===


# Given any two points <math>x \ne y \in X</math>, there exist disjoint [[open subset]]s <math>U \ni x</math> and <math>V \ni y</math>.
* [[Euclidean space]], and more generally, any [[manifold]], [[closed sub-Euclidean space|closed subset of Euclidean space]], and any [[sub-Euclidean space|subset of Euclidean space]] is Hausdorff.
# In the product space <math>X \times X</math>, endowed with the [[product topology]], the diagonal, viz., the subset given by <math>\{ (x,x) \mid x \in X \}</math> is a closed subset
* Any [[metric space]] is Hausdorff in the induced topology, i.e., any metrizable space is Hausdorff.
# If <math>S_\alpha</math> is an ultrafilter of subsets of <math>X</math>, then there is at most one <math>x \in X</math> for which <math>S_\alpha \to x</math>


==Relation with other properties==
===Non-examples===


{{pivotalproperty}}
* The [[spectrum of a commutative unital ring]] is generally ''not'' Hausdorff under the Zariski topology.
* The [[etale space of continuous functions]], and more general etale spaces, are usually ''not'' Hausdorff.


* [[:Category:Variations of Hausdorffness]]
{{pivotal topospace property}}


===Stronger properties===
{{T family|T2}}


* [[Weaker than::Normal space]]
{{basicdef}}
* [[Weaker than::Completely regular space]]
* [[Weaker than::Regular space]]
* [[Weaker than::Metrizable space]]
* [[Weaker than::CW-space]]
* [[Weaker than::Manifold]]


===Weaker properties===
==Metaproperties==


* [[Stronger than::Locally Hausdorff space]]
{| class="sortable" border="1"
* [[Stronger than::KC-space]]: This is based on the fact that any compact subset of a Hausdorff space is closed. {{proofat|[[Hausdorff implies KC]]}}
!Metaproperty name !! Satisfied? !! Proof !! Statement with symbols
* [[Stronger than::US-space]]: This is based on the fact that any convergent sequence in a Hausdorff space has a unique limit. {{proofat|[[Hausdorff implies US]]}}
|-
* [[Stronger than::Sober space]]
| [[satisfies metaproperty::product-closed property of topological spaces]] || Yes || [[Hausdorffness is product-closed]] || If <math>X_i, i \in I</math> is a (finite or infinite) collection of Hausdorff topological spaces, the product of all the <math>X_i</math>s, equipped with the [[product topology]], is also Hausdorff.
* [[Stronger than::T1 space]]
|-
* [[Stronger than::T0 space]]
| [[satisfies metaproperty::box product-closed property of topological spaces]] || Yes || [[Hausdorffness is box product-closed]] || If <math>X_i, i \in I</math> is a (finite or infinite) collection of Hausdorff topological spaces, the product of all the <math>X_i</math>s, equipped with the [[box topology]], is also Hausdorff.
|-
| [[satisfies metaproperty::subspace-hereditary property of topological spaces]] || Yes || [[Hausdorffness is hereditary]] || Suppose <math>X</math> is a Hausdorff space and <math>A</math> is a subset of <math>X</math>. Under the [[subspace topology]], <math>A</math> is also Hausdorff.
|-
| [[satisfies metaproperty::refining-preserved property of topological spaces]] || Yes || [[Hausdorffness is refining-preserved]] || Suppose <math>\tau_1</math> and <math>\tau_2</math> are two topologies on a set <math>X</math>, such that <math>\tau_1 \subseteq \tau_2</math>, i.e., every subset of <math>X</math> open with respect to <math>\tau_1</math> is also open with respect to <math>\tau_2</math>. Then, if <math>X</math> is Hausdorff with respect to <math>\tau_1</math>, it is also Hausdorff with respect to <math>\tau_2</math>.
|-
| [[dissatisfies metaproperty::local property of topological spaces]] || No || [[Hausdorffness is not local]] || It is possible to have a topological space <math>X</math> such that, for every <math>x \in X</math>, there exists an open subset <math>U \ni x</math> that is Hausdorff but <math>X</math> is not itself Hausdorff. Spaces with this property are called [[locally Hausdorff space]]s.
|-
| [[satisfies metaproperty::closure-local property of topological spaces]] || Yes || [[Hausdorffness is closure-local]] || If <math>X</math> is a topological space such that, for every <math>x \in X</math>, there exists an open subset <math>U \ni x</math> such that the closure <math>\overline{U}</math> is Hausdorff, then <math>X</math> is Hausdorff.
|}


==Metaproperties==
==Relation with other properties==


{{DP-closed}}
===Stronger properties===


An arbitrary (finite or infinite) product of Hausdorff spaces is Hausdorff. {{proofat|[[Hausdorffness is product-closed]]}}
{| class="sortable" border="1"
! Property !! Meaning !! Proof of implication !! Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) !! Intermediate notions
|-
| [[Weaker than::normal Hausdorff space]] || <math>T_1</math> and any two disjoint closed subsets are separated by disjoint open subsets ||  || [[Hausdorff not implies normal]] || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|normal Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::collectionwise normal Hausdorff space]] || <math>T_1</math> and [[collectionwise normal space|collectionwise normal]]: any discrete collection of closed subsets is separated by disjoint open subsets || (via normal) || (via normal) || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|collectionwise normal Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::regular Hausdorff space]] || <math>T_1</math> and any point and closed subset not containing it are separated by disjoint open subsets ||  || [[Hausdorff not implies regular]] || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|regular Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::Tychonoff space]] || <math>T_1</math> and [[completely regular space|completely regular]]: any point and disjoint closed subset are separated by a continuous function to <math>[0,1]</math> || (via regular) || (via regular) || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|completely regular Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::collectionwise Hausdorff space]] || any discrete set of points can be separated by disjoint open subsets || [[collectionwise Hausdorff implies Hausdorff]] || [[Hausdorff not implies collectionwise Hausdorff]] || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|collectionwise Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::functionally Hausdorff space]] || any two distinct points can be separated by a continuous function to the reals || || || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|functionally Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::Urysohn space]] || any two distinct points can be separated by closure-disjoint open subsets || || || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|Urysohn space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::metrizable space]] || underlying topology of a [[metric space]] || [[metrizable implies Hausdorff]] || [[Hausdorff not implies metrizable]] || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|metrizable space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::CW-space]] || underlying topological space of a [[CW-complex]] || [[CW implies Hausdorff]] || [[Hausdorff not implies CW]] || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|CW-space}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::manifold]] || || || || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|manifold}}
|-
| [[Weaker than::submetrizable space]] || either metrizable or can be made metrizable by passage to a [[coarser topology]] || || || {{intermediate notions short|Hausdorff space|submetrizable space}}
|}


{{subspace-closed}}
===Weaker properties===


Any subspace of a Hausdorff space is Hausdorff. {{proofat|[[Hausdorffness is hereditary]]}}
{| class="sortable" border="1"
! Property !! Meaning !! Proof of implication !! Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) !! Intermediate notions
|-
| [[Stronger than::preregular space]] || any two [[topologically distinguishable points]] can be separated by pairwise disjoint open subsets || direct || || {{intermediate notions short|preregular space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::locally Hausdorff space]] || every point is contained in an open subset that's Hausdorff || [[Hausdorff implies locally Hausdorff]] || [[locally Hausdorff not implies Hausdorff]] || {{intermediate notions short|locally Hausdorff space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::weakly Hausdorff space]] || any subset of it that is the image of a compact Hausdorff space under a continuous map is closed in it || || || {{intermediate notions short|weakly Hausdorff space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::KC-space]] || every compact subset is closed ||[[Hausdorff implies KC]] || [[KC not implies Hausdorff]] || {{intermediate notions short|KC-space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::US-space]] || every convergent sequence has a unique limit || [[Hausdorff implies US]] || [[US not implies Hausdorff]] || {{intermediate notions short|US-space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::sober space]] || every irreducible subset is the closure of a single point || [[Hausdorff implies sober]] || [[sober not implies Hausdorff]] || {{intermediate notions short|sober space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::T1 space]] || every point is closed || [[Hausdorff implies T1]] || [[T1 not implies Hausdorff]] || {{intermediate notions short|T1 space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::sober T1 space]] || sober and T1 || (via both components of conjunction) || || {{intermediate notions short|sober T1 space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::Kolmogorov space]] (also called <math>T_0</math>) || any two distinct points are topologically distinguishable || || || {{intermediate notions short|Kolmogorov space|Hausdorff space}}
|-
| [[Stronger than::sober T0 space]] || sober and Kolmogorov || || || {{intermediate notions short|sober T0 space|Hausdorff space}}
|}


{{refining-preserved}}
===Opposite properties===


Moving to a finer topology increases the number of possible open sets to choose from, and hence, preserves the property of Hausdorffness. {{proofat|[[Hausdorffness is refining-preserved]]}}
* [[Irreducible space]]: See [[irreducible and Hausdorff implies one-point space]]
* [[Ultraconnected space]]: See [[ultraconnected and T1 implies one-point space]]


==References==
==References==
Line 70: Line 143:
* {{booklink-defined|Munkres}}, Page 98, Chapter 2, Section 17 (formal definition)
* {{booklink-defined|Munkres}}, Page 98, Chapter 2, Section 17 (formal definition)
* {{booklink-defined|SingerThorpe}}, Page 26 (formal definition)
* {{booklink-defined|SingerThorpe}}, Page 26 (formal definition)
==External links==
===Definition links===
* {{wp|Hausdorff space}}

Latest revision as of 01:36, 5 January 2017

Please also read the Topospaces Convention page: Convention:Hausdorffness assumption

Definition

Equivalent definitions in tabular format

A topological space is said to be Hausdorff if it satisfies the following equivalent conditions:

No. Shorthand A topological space is termed Hausdorff if ... A topological space is termed Hausdorff if ...
1 Separation axiom given any two distinct points in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets containing the two points respectively. given any two points , there exist open subsets and such that is empty
2 Diagonal in square the diagonal is closed in the product of the space with itself in the product space , endowed with the product topology, the diagonal, viz., the subset given by is a closed subset
3 Ultrafilter convergence every ultrafilter of subsets converges to at most one point if is an ultrafilter of subsets of , then there is at most one for which .
4 Separation axiom for finite subsets given any finite collection of distinct points the topological space, there are open subsets containing each of the points in that finite subset that have pairwise trivial intersection. for any finite collection of distinct points in , there exists a finite collection of open subsets of such that for all and is empty for .
5 Separation axiom using basis open subsets (choose a basis of open subsets for the topological space) given any two distinct points in the topological space, there are disjoint open sets from the basis containing the two points respectively. (choose a basis of open subsets for the topological space) given any two points , there exist open subsets and such that both and are in the basis and is empty
6 Separation axiom for finite subsets using basis open subsets (choose a basis of open subsets for the topological space) given any finite collection of distinct points the topological space, there are open subsets (all from the basis) containing each of the points in that finite subset that have pairwise trivial intersection. for any finite collection of distinct points in , there exists a finite collection of open subsets of (all from the basis) such that for all and is empty for .
7 Separation axiom for two compact subsets any two disjoint compact subsets can be separated by disjoint open subsets given any compact subsets of (i.e., are both compact spaces in the subspace topology), there exist disjoint open subsets such that and .
8 Separation axiom for finitely many compact subsets any finite collection of pairwise disjoint compact subsets can be separated by a finite collection of pairwise disjoint open subsets given a finite collection of pairwise disjoint compact subsets of , there exist pairwise disjoint open subsets of such that for each .
9 Separation axiom between point and compact subset given any point and any compact subset not contianing it, the point and the compact subset can be separated by disjoint open subsets. for any and any such that is compact and , there exist disjoint open subsets of such that .
10 preregular and Kolmogorov it is both a preregular space and a Kolmogorov space (i.e., a space)

Equivalence of definitions

Further information: equivalence of definitions of Hausdorff space

Examples

Extreme examples

  • The empty space is a Hausdorff space. For this space, the Hausdorffness condition is vacuously satisfied.
  • The one-point space is a Hausdorff space. For this space, the Hausdorffness condition is vacuously satisfied.
  • Any discrete space (i.e., a topological space with the discrete topology) is a Hausdorff space.

Typical examples

Non-examples

This article defines a property of topological space that is pivotal (viz important) among currently studied properties of topological spaces

In the T family (properties of topological spaces related to separation axioms), this is called: T2


This article is about a basic definition in topology.
VIEW: Definitions built on this | Facts about this | Survey articles about this
View a complete list of basic definitions in topology

Metaproperties

Metaproperty name Satisfied? Proof Statement with symbols
product-closed property of topological spaces Yes Hausdorffness is product-closed If is a (finite or infinite) collection of Hausdorff topological spaces, the product of all the s, equipped with the product topology, is also Hausdorff.
box product-closed property of topological spaces Yes Hausdorffness is box product-closed If is a (finite or infinite) collection of Hausdorff topological spaces, the product of all the s, equipped with the box topology, is also Hausdorff.
subspace-hereditary property of topological spaces Yes Hausdorffness is hereditary Suppose is a Hausdorff space and is a subset of . Under the subspace topology, is also Hausdorff.
refining-preserved property of topological spaces Yes Hausdorffness is refining-preserved Suppose and are two topologies on a set , such that , i.e., every subset of open with respect to is also open with respect to . Then, if is Hausdorff with respect to , it is also Hausdorff with respect to .
local property of topological spaces No Hausdorffness is not local It is possible to have a topological space such that, for every , there exists an open subset that is Hausdorff but is not itself Hausdorff. Spaces with this property are called locally Hausdorff spaces.
closure-local property of topological spaces Yes Hausdorffness is closure-local If is a topological space such that, for every , there exists an open subset such that the closure is Hausdorff, then is Hausdorff.

Relation with other properties

Stronger properties

Property Meaning Proof of implication Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) Intermediate notions
normal Hausdorff space and any two disjoint closed subsets are separated by disjoint open subsets Hausdorff not implies normal Functionally Hausdorff space, Regular Hausdorff space, Tychonoff space, Urysohn space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
collectionwise normal Hausdorff space and collectionwise normal: any discrete collection of closed subsets is separated by disjoint open subsets (via normal) (via normal) |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
regular Hausdorff space and any point and closed subset not containing it are separated by disjoint open subsets Hausdorff not implies regular Urysohn space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Tychonoff space and completely regular: any point and disjoint closed subset are separated by a continuous function to (via regular) (via regular) Functionally Hausdorff space, Regular Hausdorff space, Urysohn space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
collectionwise Hausdorff space any discrete set of points can be separated by disjoint open subsets collectionwise Hausdorff implies Hausdorff Hausdorff not implies collectionwise Hausdorff |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
functionally Hausdorff space any two distinct points can be separated by a continuous function to the reals Urysohn space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Urysohn space any two distinct points can be separated by closure-disjoint open subsets |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
metrizable space underlying topology of a metric space metrizable implies Hausdorff Hausdorff not implies metrizable Collectionwise Hausdorff space, Completely regular space, Functionally Hausdorff space, Monotonically normal space, Moore space, Normal Hausdorff space, Regular Hausdorff space, Submetrizable space, Tychonoff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
CW-space underlying topological space of a CW-complex CW implies Hausdorff Hausdorff not implies CW Completely regular space, Normal Hausdorff space, Regular Hausdorff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
manifold Metrizable space, Monotonically normal space, Submetrizable space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
submetrizable space either metrizable or can be made metrizable by passage to a coarser topology Functionally Hausdorff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO

Weaker properties

Property Meaning Proof of implication Proof of strictness (reverse implication failure) Intermediate notions
preregular space any two topologically distinguishable points can be separated by pairwise disjoint open subsets direct |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
locally Hausdorff space every point is contained in an open subset that's Hausdorff Hausdorff implies locally Hausdorff locally Hausdorff not implies Hausdorff |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
weakly Hausdorff space any subset of it that is the image of a compact Hausdorff space under a continuous map is closed in it |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
KC-space every compact subset is closed Hausdorff implies KC KC not implies Hausdorff Weakly Hausdorff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
US-space every convergent sequence has a unique limit Hausdorff implies US US not implies Hausdorff KC-space, Weakly Hausdorff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
sober space every irreducible subset is the closure of a single point Hausdorff implies sober sober not implies Hausdorff Sober T0 space, Sober T1 space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
T1 space every point is closed Hausdorff implies T1 T1 not implies Hausdorff KC-space, Locally Hausdorff space, Sober T1 space, Weakly Hausdorff space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
sober T1 space sober and T1 (via both components of conjunction) |FULL LIST, MORE INFO
Kolmogorov space (also called ) any two distinct points are topologically distinguishable KC-space, Locally Hausdorff space, Sober T0 space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO
sober T0 space sober and Kolmogorov Sober T1 space|FULL LIST, MORE INFO

Opposite properties

References

Textbook references

  • Topology (2nd edition) by James R. MunkresMore info, Page 98, Chapter 2, Section 17 (formal definition)
  • Lecture Notes on Elementary Topology and Geometry (Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics) by I. M. Singer and J. A. ThorpeMore info, Page 26 (formal definition)